michaelcrook.ca

Blogs are about people. I'm going to use this place to share a bit about what I'm thinking, what I'm reading and what I'm doing. I hope its a conversation you feel like joining. Please send me an e-mail

Friday, January 27, 2006

More Election Aftermath

The recent election of a Hamas majority in the Palestine elections has been making a lot more press internationally than it has here at home. Both the US and Canada have labelled Hamas a terrorist organisation but they are now a legitimate political authority in one of the least stable political situations in the world. I was concerned when I read this.

I'm not at all an expert on the situation in the middle east or the nuances of the Israeli-Palestinian conflict but it occurs to me that bankrupting the Palestinian Authority will encourage more extremism rather than less. With the legitimization of Hamas, and the Defeat of a scandal-prone Fatah party, the international community needs to look long and hard at whether received wisdom and convention has any hope of maintaining stability. I'm convinced a rethinking of the issues surrounding this entrenched conflict is the only hope Palestinians or Iraelis have of finding solutions.

Here in Canada, under Paul Martin, our foreign service had been slowly shifting towards support for Israel. It is widely expected that a Conservative government (particularly one with Stockwell Day as Minister of Foreign Affairs) would morph into a group of staunchly pro-Israel cheerleaders. The ascension of Hamas would provide legitimate justification for such a planned policy shift and would encourage similar shifts throughout the EU. It is possible that the future legitimacy of the Authority is in terrific jeopardy.

2 Comments:

At 6:17 PM, Blogger Michael Crook said...

I guess it's not a simple point from my perspective but I'm far from well educated on the issue. I cede the point of giving credence to an organisation like Hamas and legitimizing there government. The other side of the coin however is that there is a population living in Palestine who need the government the authority provides to maintain any kind of normal life. The danger in abandoning aid is, in my view, that this kind of "retaliation" plays directly into the message of Hamas and would risk further strengthening their support in a place where there are very few reasons for hope.

 
At 11:52 AM, Anonymous Anonymous said...

In the 1940's there was a country, democraticly elected, whose main platform was the erradication of Jews and the Jewish state...of course we defeated them. 2006..same story different country, and there is a debate in this country as to how to handle this delicate little situation. I honestly dont see the problem. We already had a dialogue with them, denounce terrorism and denounce the anti-Israeli platform, then we really really talk. Seems pretty simple to me. Lets make it easier. They want all Jews dead. We dont. Boy, what to do...what to do. Maybe I'm being simple, if someone wanted me and my family dead I'm not too sure I'd be willing to let them in my house unless I checked them for weapons first...

 

Post a Comment

<< Home